Header

Search

Think Negative – Carbon Dioxide Removal und Carbon Offset

Event description

According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), negative emissions technologies are essential for achieving net-zero emissions, especially since a surplus of emissions is expected that must be removed from the atmosphere. In this German lecture moderated by Lisa Mangertseder (DVNE; Carbon Removal Partners), Dr. Johanna Puetz (BCG), Dr. Sophie Wenger (BAFU) and Dr. Jan Wurzbacher (Climeworks) discussed key questions: How effective are these offsetting mechanisms? What technological solutions for CO₂ removal already exist? What regulatory frameworks are necessary for the scalable implementation of these technologies?

Recording

Written summary of the input presentations

Input 1: Dr. Johanna Puetz (Managing Director and Partner, Boston Consulting Group (BCG))

  • The world is not reducing its emissions quickly enough. We are currently heading towards approximately 3–4 degrees of global warming. To achieve the 1.5-degree target, emissions would have to decrease much faster and more significantly.

  • The path to net zero:

    • At least 90 percent of the solution lies in reducing and avoiding emissions.

    • Another 5 to 10 percent must be achieved through CO₂ removal, as there is a portion of emissions that cannot be avoided.

  • CO₂ removal = CO₂ is extracted (captured) from the air and stored through:
    • Natural methods, e.g., reforestation
    • Human-accelerated natural processes, e.g., processing organic waste into biochar and storing it in the soil
    • Technology-based removal, e.g., direct CO2 capture and storage from the air
  • In addition to climate protection, this topic is also economically attractive, as it represents a new industry that creates jobs and fosters innovation.
  • Currently, political uncertainty, high costs, immature technologies, funding gaps, and complex permitting processes are considered the biggest obstacles to scaling up CO2 removal.
  • Take-home message: In addition to emissions reduction, we need a mix of methods for CO2 removal. Expanding these methods requires more political support, more investment, and technological development.

Input 2: Dr. Jan Wurzbacher (Co-CEO and Co-Founder, Climeworks)

  • If we want to comply with the Paris Climate Agreement, 6 to 16 gigatons of CO2 per year must be removed from the atmosphere by 2050.

  • To achieve this, the CO2 removal industry must grow by a factor of 1000. Other transition examples show that scaling technologies on this scale is possible.

  • Although there is too much CO2, it is highly diluted in the atmosphere, and large facilities are needed to remove approximately 1 in every 2500 atmospheric particles, which is CO2. Suitable locations with stable political conditions must be found for this.

  • Important steps for scaling include:

    • Gaining practical experience in building and operating facilities

    • Further developing the technology, e.g., better filters, cost reduction

    • Finding suitable locations and building infrastructure

  • Take-home message: CO₂ removal is necessary to achieve the set climate targets. Since the technology is currently still expensive, investment, innovation, and scaling are needed.

Input 3: Dr. Sophie Wenger (Climate Policy Officer, Bundesamt für Umwelt (BAFU), the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment)

  • Switzerland aims to be climate-neutral (net zero) by 2050 by avoiding as many emissions as possible and eliminating the remaining, difficult-to-avoid emissions through carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon dioxide removal (CDR).

  • Emissions that are difficult to avoid occur, for example, in the areas of international aviation, industry, and agriculture.

  • CCS could reduce approximately 5 million tons of CO2 annually, while CDR could offset 8 to 9 million tons of CO2 annually.

  • CDR in the form of bioenergy CCS is already taking place in Switzerland, for example, by capturing CO2 in biogas plants and subsequently storing it domestically in concrete. Initial projects are also exporting CO2 to countries such as Iceland or Denmark for permanent storage in deep underground reservoirs.

  • Where projects are underway, there are government funding programs, foundations involved, and/or local support projects.

  • Current climate policy incentives (selection):

    • Crediting of CCS and CDR measures in climate policy instruments

    • Funding for innovative technologies and processes for net-zero emissions

    • Net-zero roadmaps for companies

  • A robust legal framework is being developed for the period after 2030, which, among other things, aims to create greater investment security for CCS and CDR and is also consistent with environmental protection. The consultation process (public consultation) is expected to begin in the second half of 2026.

Portrait Lisa Mangertseder (moderator)

Lisa Mangertseder is a Venture Associate at Carbon Removal Partners, a Swiss venture capital investment advisor focused on investments in the emerging carbon dioxide removal (“CDR”) industry. CRP identifies and assesses early-stage companies and technologies in Switzerland, Europe and North America and provides access to capital. Lisa further serves as Vice-Chair of the Deutscher Verband für Negative Emissionen (DVNE), Europe’s first national carbon removal association, founded in 2023 to advance carbon dioxide removal (CDR) technologies and policies. Lastly, Lisa is the founder and co-lead of Women in Carbon Switzerland, a 200-member association designed to empower and amplify the voices of women in the carbon industry.
Overall, Lisa is actively involved in building the carbon removal ecosystem in Germany and Europe, working with stakeholders across industry, policy, and research to accelerate the development and deployment of CDR solutions. Her expertise includes carbon removal technologies and markets, policy.

Portrait Dr. Johanna Puetz (speaker)

Dr. Johanna Puetz is a Managing Director and Partner at Boston Consulting Group (BCG), where she has been since 2011. She is a core member of BCG's Climate & Sustainability and Industrial Goods practice areas and leads BCG’s Climate & Sustainability business in Central Europe. Dr. Puetz works with industrial clients, especially in the automotive industry, on sustainability strategies and transformation, net-zero, and circular economy. She holds a PhD in innovation economics and renewable energy from the Wuppertal Climate Institute, a Master's in Management (CEMS) from the London School of Economics and HEC Paris, and a BA in European studies from Maastricht University. In addition to her client work, she is the Honorary Chairperson of the Berlin branch of JOBLINGE, a BCG-initiated NGO for labor market participation and integration. 

Portrait Dr. Sophie Wenger (speaker)

Dr. Sophie Wenger is a Climate Policy Officer at the Bundesamt für Umwelt (BAFU), the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment. She holds a PhD in physical chemistry from the Ecole polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL). In her role at BAFU, she develops the legal frameworks and national and international cooperations needed to scale carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon dioxide removal (CDR) in the context of the Swiss net-zero climate target. She also manages Switzerland’s national CCS/CDR working group, which brings together public authorities, industry, academia, and civil society to help accelerate the deployment of these necessary technologies in a responsible manner.

Portrait Dr. Jan Wurzbacher (speaker)

Dr. Jan Wurzbacher is the Co-CEO and Co-Founder of Climeworks, one of the global leaders in developing direct air capture technology for carbon removal. Together with Christoph Gebald, he is responsible for the management of the company, which has been capturing CO₂ from air since 2009. Jan is a mechanical engineer who earned his doctorate from ETH Zurich. Under his leadership, Climeworks has become a pioneering force in the fight against climate change, developing scalable solutions to remove CO₂ directly from the atmosphere and either store it permanently underground or use it in various applications. He and Christoph Gebald were named to TIME100 Climate 2023 for their groundbreaking work in carbon removal technology. Besides Climeworks, Jan is dedicated to windsurfing, skiing, and discovering new places. His work is focused on making carbon removal a key tool in achieving global climate goals.